The Reverend Daniel Shaver, 1861-1862
The Reverend J. M. Curtis, 1865
The Reverend H. B. Monges, 1867-1869
The Reverend Lindsey P. Rucker, 1870-1871, 1874-1884
The Reverend W. W. Patrick, 1886-1887
The Reverend Charles F. Denroche, 1888-1889
The Reverend Thomas B. Lawson, 1891-1895
The Reverend B. A. Rogers, 1896-1897
The Reverend G. E. Lloyd, 1898
The Reverend James Noble, 1899-1900
The Reverend T. J. Windham, 1902-1903
The Reverend S. Moylan Bird, 1905-1921
The Reverend Ira D. Lang, 1921-1925
The Reverend Thomas N. Lawrence, 1925-1927
The Reverend Eugene Clark, 1927-1929
The Reverend Frank H. Stallknecht, 1930-1945
The Reverend C. Wayne Buchanan, 1945-1949
The Reverend Ralph E. Dille, 1950-1955
The Reverend Fred Kepler, 1955-1956
The Reverend Jack D. Russell, 1958-1962
The Reverend H. Donald Keeling, Jr., 1963-1967
The Reverend A. Phillips Nazro, Jr., 1968-1970
The Reverend Marshall Mason, Jr., 1970-1977
The Reverend George Floyd, 1977-1981
The Reverend Thomas A. Wallace, 1981-1998
The Reverend Robert L. Gribble, 1999-2009
The Reverend Dr. David W. Hoster, 2010-2012
The Reverend James M. Pevehouse, 2013-2018